(AFRICAN AMERICAN NEWSWIRE)Washington, D.C., April
21, 2004 -- The majority of African-American physicians
are not satisfied with their experience in the daily
practice of medicine, according to the first-ever
survey of African-American physicians' perceptions
of the medical profession which was released today
at the National Press Club. Limited access to health
insurance for their patients, cost of medical liability
insurance, and physician reimbursement were among
the leading causes cited for physicians' dissatisfaction,
with nearly one-quarter of those physicians surveyed
indicating "the loss of joy in medicine as a
primary or major reason" for making changes in
their practice.
Overwhelmingly, respondents view improved access
of minority patients to health insurance as a priority.
Ninety percent of physicians surveyed indicate disparities
in healthcare access as being "extremely important"
for the medical profession to address, followed closely
by tort reform (88%) and reimbursement (83%). These
issues accounted for the top-three areas of professional
disaffection experienced by physicians surveyed. Seventy-three
percent indicated no satisfaction with their medical
liability coverage, and nearly one-fifth (18%) reported
that obtaining professional medical liability insurance
was "the biggest problem I've faced this year."
Indeed, almost half (46%) of the respondents said
they had some degree of difficulty in getting such
insurance. The majority (61.5%) stated that their
medical liability insurance cost "went up significantly"
or "went up somewhat" in the last three
years. Paying for liability was a problem for nearly
two-thirds (65%), with cost ranking as "the biggest
problem I faced" for more than one-fourth of
physicians (27%).
"The survey findings point to the frustrating
reality we in the profession confront daily. We chose
to pursue the practice of medicine because we wanted
to heal our patients, to provide them with the highest
level of care," said Sharon Allison-Ottey, MD,
Physician, Researcher and co-investigator of the survey.
"Rather than being able to focus on the medical
needs of our patients, however, we increasingly find
ourselves justifying the prescriptions we chose to
treat them, or fighting for reimbursement for our
medical services, or addressing ever-mounting medical
liability costs and issues. Indeed, we must reform
our nation's medical liability system so as to stop
skyrocketing costs that cripple our practices. How
can we provide medical care to our patients, when
we simply can no longer afford it?"
Physicians surveyed also indicate the increase in
paperwork, stress in their practice, amount of time
they can devote to each patient, and patient load
as additional reasons they are "not at all satisfied"
with their daily practice of medicine. Faced with
increasing challenges in their practice, more than
3 out of 4 (76%) of the respondents reported they
either have retired within the last year or expect
to retire from the profession in the near future.
While physicians of African descent make up only
3% to 5% of the physician population, more than two-thirds
(67%) of their patients are minority patients. The
majority of African-Americans physicians practice
in large urban areas or suburbs, according to the
survey.
The nationwide survey, which was sponsored by the
National Medical Association (NMA) and the Gallup
Organization, and supported by an unrestricted educational
grant from Pfizer Pharmaceuticals, Inc., questioned
479 NMA physicians about the state of medical practice
as perceived by African-American physicians; major
obstacles to practice; satisfaction with specific
aspects of medicine; and changes made by physicians
in the new environment. The survey findings will be
published in the April 2004 issue of Journal of the
National Medical Association.
Additional Survey Highlights
l Across the board,
a significant majority (from over 50% to over 60%)
of physicians say they have "personally experienced
a problem or annoyance" in reimbursement from
a private managed care plan, commercial health insurance
plan, state Medicaid or medical assistance, or Medicare
l The overwhelming majority
say they are "not at all satisfied" with
changes in Medicare reimbursement (50%) and with changes
in Medicare reimbursement (45%)
l More than half (55%)
are "not at all satisfied" state Medicaid
or medical assistance reimbursement
l Nearly three-quarters
state "not at all satisfied," when asked
about private managed care reimbursement (39%) and
commercial health insurance reimbursement (34%)
l Nearly 50% indicate
"low satisfaction" with the treatment of
African-American physicians in managed care
Despite the levels of dissatisfaction and changes
to practice cited, nearly 4 out of 10 (37.9%) of those
physicians surveyed also express "passion"
for their profession. "The saving grace for the
physician and thus the health of this nation's minority
patient is the passion that remains with these physicians;
they continue to view their profession as irreplaceable,"
said Randall W. Maxey, M.D., President of the National
Medical Association. "We fully intend to harness
that passion and nurture it, moving forward.
The survey respondents let us know that issues of
disparity in patient access to health insurance; ever-increasing
medical liability; and changes in physician reimbursement
are the top-three activities we must champion. The
NMA has historically been a strong advocate for the
physician and for the patients we serve. The NMA invites
other national, regional, and local societies, government
agencies and other interested organizations to join
us in our efforts."
About the Survey
The survey was conducted July 2003, using a mail methodology
of physicians from the NMA list subset. Of the surveys
mailed, 479 surveys were completed, with the largest
majority (70.1 %) of respondents between the ages
of 35-64 years of age. The respondents included 56%
men and 44% women. The median date of residency was
1984. Nearly 45% of the respondents had served 10
or more years in their current practice. Data entry
and analysis were performed by the Gallup Organization,
using standard analytical methodology found to be
statistically significant and relevant for public
discussion.
-30-
About the National Medical Association
Founded in 1895, the NMA is the one of the oldest
and largest of the nation's medical associations,
representing the interests of more than 25,000 African-American
physicians and their patients. The NMA is committed
to improving the quality of health among minorities
and underserved people. For additional information,
visit www.nmanet.org